Every sport evolves with each passing generation -- from the
size and athleticism of players to game strategy.
Baseball’s evolution, however, is both historic and unique given
the pre-integration and dead ball eras. For the former, full
segregation took place from 1887-1947. Full integration, which
was a gradual process, came in 1959. The Deadball Era was a
period in the early 20th century when baseball was characterized
by low scoring and emphasis on pitching.
There was the Steroid Era, which has no definite start time though
it is generally assumed that the era ran from the late 1980s until the
late 2000s. This era was defined by shattered home run records
leading to exorbitant salaries.
The St. Louis Cardinals have been a Major League Baseball
franchise since 1892. The franchise has 11 World Series titles and
19 National League pennants to its resume.
Today, I formed a Cardinals Dream Team that encompasses all
eras. For openers, to make this roster, four years as a Cardinal are
required. No exceptions. With the free agency era, I’m not going to
cheapen this roster with 1-3 year rentals.
I’m forming a 12 man pitching staff, five starters and seven relievers.
For the latter, I want at least one lefthander in the bullpen. For
position players, I am taking what I believe is the best of the best
regardless of era. For the bench players, it’s the best of the rest with
versatility being heavily considered. Merit achievements such as
Hall of Fame, All Star appearances and Gold Gloves are considered
but not guaranteed. General impactfulness on the franchise is also
considered.
Generational reminders
If I believe you were the best at your position in the pre-integration
era, you are on the team. If you played on a World Series champion,
there is no guarantee of landing on this roster. If you played during
a bad season, that does not deter you from being on this roster.
Unlike the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame, there are no morality
clauses. This is baseball, not the Boys Scouts.
Starting pitchers
Bob Gibson, Dizzy Dean, Jesse Haines, Steve Carlton, John
Tudor
One would have to look long and hard to find a more intimidating
pitcher in Major League history than Gibson. On the way to a Hall of
Fame career, he was a nine-time All-Star, nine-time Gold Glove Award
winner, two time World Series MVP, two-time National League Cy
Young Award winner and National League MVP in 1968. Gibson one
251 games and pitched 255 complete games. On the way to a Hall
of Fame career, Dean was the National League MVP in 1934 and
won 30 games that season, becoming the first National Leaguer to
reach that total since 1917 and the last one to do it. Dean was a
four-time All-Star and helped deliver the Cardinals 1934 World Series
champion. That season he was the National League MVP. Haynes
pitched 18 seasons with the Cardinals and remains second and wins
and complete games behind Gibson. On the way to a Hall of Fame
career, he helped deliver three World Series Championships.
Carlton spent most of his Hall of Fame career with the Philadelphia
Phillies but also had seven impactful seasons with the Cardinals. In
a St. Louis uniform, Carlton helped deliver the franchise’s 1967
World Series title and was a three-time All-Star. Tudor was the
epitome of a finesse pitcher and won 62 games in his five seasons
with the Cardinals with 1985 being his peak performance. That
season, he won 21 games and helped the Cardinals reach the World
Series. He led the Major Leagues in shutouts with 10 and ERA at
1.93.
Bullpen
Closer -- Jason Isringhausen
Bruce Sutter, Todd worrell, Lee Smith, Al Hrabosky, Trevor Rosenthal,
Lindy McDaniel
Isringhausen recorded 300 career saves, 217 came in a Cardinals
uniform. Isringhausen compiled a 2.98 ERA in a Cardinals uniform
and 2.36 in the postseason. Though he missed the 2006 playoffs,
Isringhausen delivered a lot of greatness in his seven seasons with
the Cardinals. Sutter popularized the split-finger fastball on the way to
becoming a dominant closer. Sutter led the National League in saves
in three of his four seasons in a Cardinals uniform. Sutter was an All-
Star twice and helped deliver the Cardinals 1982 World Series
championship. On the way to a Hall of Fame career, Smith recorded
478 career saves with only Mariano Rivera and Trevor Hoffman
recording more. Smith recorded 160 saves in a four-year span with
the Cardinals. He was an All-Star twice and led the National League
in saves twice in a St. Louis uniform.
Worrell made an immediate impact with the Cardinals and won
National League Rookie of the Year honors in 1986. That season he
led the National League in saves and was the National League
Rolaids Relief Man Award winner. Hrabosky spent eight seasons with
the Cardinals and was the National League saves leader in 1975. Arm
trouble ended Rosenthal's career with the Cardinals after six seasons.
He was an All-Star in 2015 and in back-to-back seasons, he recorded
45 and 48 saves. McDaniel's versatility earns him a spot on this roster
because he alternated between starter and reliever, in the process
recording 66 wins and 66 saves along with four seasons in which he
recorded double-figure victories. McDaniel was a two-time All-Star.
Infield
Catcher -- Yadier Molina, First base -- Albert Pujols, Second base --
Rogers Hornsby, Third base -- Ken Boyer, Shortstop -- Ozzie Smith
Molina's legacy is still in progress but is still quite amazing even if he
never plays another inning of baseball. In Molina’s 17 year career, all
with the Cardinals, he is a nine-time All-Star, nine-time Gold Glove
Award winner and has delivered two World Series Championships for
the Cardinals. Pujols was drafted in the 13th round of the 1999 draft
and became an all-time great player. Pujols was a three-time National
League MVP, 10 time All Star, six-time Silver Slugger Award winner,
two-time Gold Glove Award winner and 2003 batting title. Although it's
easy to focus on his hitting exploits, Pujols became an above-
average defensive player and base runner.
Hornsby is still considered by many to be the best second baseman
of all time and for good reason. On the way to a Hall of Fame career,
he was a seven-time National League batting champion, two-time
Triple Crown winner, two-time National League MVP, two-time National
League home run leader and four-time National League RBI leader.
He helped deliver the Cardinals their 1926 World Series championship.
Boyer was a centerpiece for the Cardinals, especially in the 1960s. He
spent 11 seasons in St Louis, seven as an All-Star. He was a five-time
Gold Glove Award winner, National League RBI leader in 1964. He
also won the MVP this season and helped deliver the Cardinals their
World Series championship. Smith is known for his spectacular
defense, and rightfully so, because he was a 13 time Gold Glove
Award winner on the way to a Hall of Fame career but he gradually
got better throughout his career as a hitter in amassing 2,460 career
base hits. Smith was a 15 time All Star who helped the Cardinals
deliver their 1982 world series title and he helped them win two more
pennants as well. He was the NLCS MVP in 1985.
Outfield
Leftfield -- Lou Brock, Centerfield -- Jim Edmonds, Rightfield --
Stan Musial
Brock was the stolen base king for both a single-season and career
records until Rickey Henderson broke both marks. Brock led the
National League in stolen bases eight times and the Major Leagues
on four other occasions. On the way to a Hall of Fame career, Brock
was a six-time All-Star and helped deliver two World Series titles for
the Cardinals. In centerfield, the Cardinals have an embarrassment
of riches but Edmunds gets the top choice with this team. In his eight
seasons with the Cardinals, he was a five-time Gold Glove Award
winner and three-time All-Star. He was a Silver Slugger Award winner
in 2004 and helped deliver the 2006 World Series title. Musial spent
all 22 seasons of his Hall of Fame career with the Cardinals and
might be the best player in franchise history regardless of position.
Musial spent a one year hiatus serving the US Navy but was a 20-
time All Star, seven-time National League batting champion, three-
time National League MVP, two-time National League RBI leader
and helped deliver three World Series titles for the Cardinals.
Bench
Ted Simmons, Johnny Mize, Red Schoendienst, Scott Rolen, Enos
Slaughter, Curt Flood
On the way to a Hall of Fame career, Simmons compiled 1,389 RBIs,
ranked second among history and catchers to Yogi Berra. He is
considered one of the top hitting catchers of all time and one of the
best switch hitters. Six of Simmons' eight All-Star appearances came
in a Cardinals uniform. Mize spent six of his Hall of Fame seasons
with the Cardinals, during which time he compiled a .336 batting
average. He was second in the MVP voting in 1939 and 1940. Aside
from Pujols, there is not a better first baseman in franchise history
than Mize. You simply cannot mention the Cardinals without
mentioning Schoendienst, who on the way to a Hall of Fame career
spent 14 years as a player, 14 is a manager and 20 others in a
supporting role. Quite simply Mr. Cardinal. As a player, Schoendiest
was an All-Star nine times and helped deliver the franchise's 1946
World Series championship.
Rolen played for four different teams but the most successful stretch
of his career were his six seasons with the Cardinals. Rolen helped
deliver the franchise's 2006 World Series title. Five of his seven
career All-Star appearances came in a Cardinals uniform and he
also won three of his eight Gold Gloves in St Louis uniform. On the
way to a Hall of Fame career, Slaughter was an All-Star in 10 of his
13 Seasons with the franchise that he helped deliver two World
Series titles. Slaughter was a reliable contact hitter and was known
for his trademark intensity. He was the national league RBI leader
in 1946, the year he returned to Major League Baseball after
serving three years in the Army in World War II. Flood was a fixture
in 12 seasons after coming over in a trade from the Cincinnati Reds.
Flood was a seven-time Gold Glove Award winner, three-time All-
Star and helped the Cardinals win two World Series titles.
Some may see Mark McGwire as one who should be on this team.
He set the record for single-season home runs in 1998 before Barry
Bonds broke it four years later. McGwire’s association with PEDs
did not keep him off this team because the franchise is loaded with
too many Hall of Famers who were more impactful. McGwire made
the Oakland Athletics Dream Team.
Manager
Tony LaRussa
LaRussa, who is a Hall of Famer and recently took over the Chicago
White Sox managerial position, is third among Major League
managers with 2,728 victories and counting behind Connie Mack
and John McGraw. LaRussa is the winningest manager in franchise
history and guided the Cardinals to nine playoff appearances in his
six seasons including World Series titles in 2006 and 2011. LaRussa
took over a losing culture in 1996 and quickly turned them into
winners.
Team
1967
When you are a franchise with 11 World Series titles, you are not
without choices but the 1967 team gets the nod based on the depth
of greatness. Gibson and Brock were each in their prime of their Hall
of Fame careers. The lineup also featured two other Hall of Famers
with Carlton and Orlando Cepeda, who was the National League
MVP. The team also included Hall of Famers managing from the
dugout and front office with Schoendiest (field manager) and Musial
(general manager). On the field, the Cardinals won 101 regular
season games to win the National League pennant, outdistancing
the San Francisco Giants by 10 1/2 games and they defeated the
Boston Red Sox in the World Series.